Score: 10

"wow"

submission: The Piper's Waltz

date: December 14, 2008

wonderful job, looks very professional. i liked your choice of music, and the theme of everything being on sticks. btw, the red star on the box looks like the macy's logo XD

Score: 9

"" a thought""

submission: John McCain as President

date: December 10, 2008

poor mccain had an even tougher opponent than obama, the poor name of republicans. oh well, the people chose obama, so its finally over. and the point you raised about running out of natural gas is sad. we are using up the world's resources... i wonder if the apocalypse is near?

Score: 4

"" really disturbing""

submission: Salad Fingers Episode 2

date: December 3, 2008

way creepier than the first. the first was a kind of funny creepy, but this was disturbing creepy. it was funny though when he started singing over the rainbow. but way to creepy

Score: 9

"hmmmm"

submission: Petwoip - Meat & Grits

date: November 18, 2009

this song hurts my ears... but i still enjoy it for some reason? i guess i like the bass... i can see this song being used as torture device.

Score: 10

"ahhhhhh :)"

submission: Winterbliss

date: November 14, 2009

this song is so wonderfully relaxing. vain star is definitely my favorite song of yours, but this is a close second. the title is perfect, without even knowing the name, the first thing i would think would be icicles. the tempo is really nice, relaxing, but enough energy to keep your interest. i see this song as having 3 main voices: 0:21-0:25, 1:21-1:35, and i count the bass as a voice, because its not only insanely awesome, but even carriers the main melody at times like 2:05-2:19. you have three main themes, but always with some kind of wintry sound in the background be it the strings, or i dont even know what that is in 2:05-2:34 =/ this song is very complex, yet it is still easy to listen to and enjoy, i get more out of it every time i listen to it. the voices compliment each other so well, that it seems perfectly natural and not at all forced to have two main themes at the same time. one of my favorite parts is 2:34-2:48. you have the bass and the beginning theme going on at the same time, with two supporting melodies. the ending might have been better, but having things slow down to the sound of the wind works pretty well for this song i think. this song is easily one of my top ten favorite in the portal, 5/5 and 10/10 :D

Score: 10

"Wow."

submission: -Jupiter-

date: November 5, 2009

this one of the best songs ive heard in a while. the main theme is short and sweet. the song is the perfect length for developing the melody, long but not too drawn out. good bass. i like the ending, the huge dramatic buildup, then its just the main melody. simple yet powerful. 5/5 10/10 this song deserves it